Our website is new! We would appreciate your feedback

Join Us

Sign-In

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

The filling needs to be stiff enough to sit as a disc, not spread — that is what keeps the chocolate seal unbroken.

Aim for a thin base and a thin lid; a thick shell overwhelms the center.

Equipment

spatula
mixing bowl
saucepan

Ingredients

cook

prepare

assemble

cool

Serve

Storage

Make Ahead

Freeze

Substitutions

Powdered sugar is doing structural work here, not just sweetening — it stiffens the filling enough to hold its shape against warm chocolate.

Freeze the filling discs first and the assembly stops being fiddly.

Reviews